You no longer find gym subscriptions suitable for your needs, so you are thinking of coming up with your own gym at home. Apart from small accessories and weights, there are a bunch of fitness gadgets that will take most of your space – as well as your expenses. How do you compare a rowing machine vs. a recumbent bike then?
Both fitness machines can provide an excellent cardio workout. Moreover, apart from burning fat, they will also give your muscles some definition. They are definitely suitable for some substantial results, but then, different people have different needs. You need to start with your overall goals and go on from there – here is what you need to know. Rowing Machine vs. Recumbent BikeConsider your fitness goals
Your current fitness condition is one of the aspects you need to consider before making a decision. But on the same note, you also need to think about your fitness goals. What are you trying to achieve? Are you all about getting a better health status? Burning fat? Losing weight? Gaining muscle definition? Getting toned?
For weight loss
Are you interested in burning some calories and losing a few pounds? You probably ask yourself – which option will provide faster and better results? Generally speaking, the rowing machine will push your heart rate up. You will soon get into the fat-burning mode. Moreover, it works on your whole body when it comes to having a workout.
But then, the rowing machine is not always for everyone. If this is the first time you exercise, you may need some practice. You need to figure out the best technique. If you are not doing it by the book, you are less likely to see too much improvement. On the other hand, there are more bikers than rowers out there, so everyone knows how a bike works. The operation is way easier. You also get an extraordinary cardio workout, but then, a recumbent bike will mostly work on your lower body. Your core – abs, back, and arms – will not see any benefits. Instead, you will most likely work on your ankles, knees, calves, hips, and glutes. Therefore, based on your experience, the recumbent bike is a better choice. In terms of efficiency, the rowing machine is superior. For muscle tone
You are happy with your weight, but you could do with a bit of muscle definition and tone. Which one is better then? Comparing the rowing machine vs. recumbent bike is not easy because both of them will work on your muscles. They will both give you a good tone. Now, where do you want this muscle tone on your body?
A recumbent bike – as well as upright bikes – will work on the lower body. They will firm your thighs, butt, and legs. The rowing machine needs more muscles to operate. Most of the movement is given by legs, but your pendulum movement is just as important, not to mention the core and the arms. Apart from your legs, you will get a better muscle tone on your abs, back, arms, legs, glutes, and thighs. The same rule applies when you are just trying to improve your technique – the rowing machine wins. For muscle mass
The mass is different from the actual tone. Mass will increase the size of your muscles. You will achieve a buff appearance and look like a bodybuilder. Now, just like for other aspects, you need to think about which parts of your body you want to work on. The bike – be it recumbent or upright – will work on the lower body and legs – calves, quadriceps, and hamstrings.
If you feel like you have neglected your legs in the gym, this type of workout will give you great results in the long run. Sure, there will be a bit of influence on the core and back too, but not too much. The rowing machine is more general. You will get a full-body workout, but you will also gain mass on your shoulders, arms, and back. Such results will not occur overnight though, but in the long run. Which burns more calories – rowing machine or recumbent bike?
Both the rowing machine vs. recumbent bike will burn calories. They will do it in a similar manner – the harder you push, the more calories you will burn over a shorter period of time. Rowers are often used for HIIT workouts, and they also provide after-workout burning. You can also use bikes for HIIT workouts, but they are not as efficient.
Which is better for back or knee problems – rowing machine vs. recumbent bike?
Different situations require different results based on your current circumstances. Which option is better if you have a leg injury? It could be the ankle, the knee, or a different bone. Maybe you are just trying to get back in shape after dealing with an injury. As a general rule of thumb, recumbent bikes are associated with injury recovery.
Recumbent bikes are light and gentle on muscles. The pressure on the ankles and knees is minimal, so they can provide a good workout without affecting the area too much. At the same time, you have the option to control the overall resistance – lower or increase it based on your needs. The intensity can also be adjusted. The rowing machine will give you a better workout for the back, but it may not be the best choice for those with a back injury – or perhaps recovering from such an injury. The rowing machine is also contraindicated to those with a bad posture due to its intensity. It requires bending the knees to 90 degrees too, so it is not a good choice if you deal with pain in that area. Which has a learning curve?
In theory, you do not have to be a genius to realize how to ride a recumbent bike. Sure, it is slightly different from the classic upright bike, but the operating principles are the same – you sit down and start pedaling. Even if you cannot ride a real bike, you know how it works, though. On the other hand, people are more likely to use a bike than a boat, so rowing is not that easy for everyone.
At the same time, for a rowing workout to show some results, you will have to perform these exercises by the book. You need the right posture, as well as the right movement. If you row randomly without proper technique, you will waste both energy and time. Unless your only goal is to have cardio workouts, the recumbent bike is a better choice. Conclusion
As a short final conclusion, comparing the rowing machine vs. recumbent bike depends on more factors.
The rowing machine is ideal for those who need a cardio workout with low-impact exercises. Besides, rowing machines do not take too much space and can be inexpensive. They do not always need a power source. You will need a recumbent bike if you want something silent, you recover from an injury, you want a better aerobic level, and you want to reduce the stress on your joints. The bike is also a better choice for those who are only concerned about their legs.
0 Commentaires
Laisser une réponse. |
AuthorJack is a fitness expert and blogger. He is the main contributor for Fitness Zone. You can find the latest blogs here. If you want to know more about us, you can find it on the About page. Feel free to contact us. |